A formerly anon blogger, trying to make it honest

I’m sure there will be a flurry of posts about 9/11 over the next few days…and here are my thoughts…
For one, I saw that certain stations (some CNN) will be re-running the events live in their entirety, starting at 8:30 am tomorrow. Part of me thinks that it would be interesting to watch, with a more objective eye - as the events unfold…another part of me thinks that it’s a bit much…do we need to relive that all over again? I personally have no interest in watching the towers fall, and the Pentagon get hit, and all of the people who were hurt, killed, and lost loved ones. I mean, I know that things shouldn’t just be pushed aside and ignored…but shouldn’t there be a better way to honor heroes and remember lives lost than watching it happen all over again?*
Then of course there is the ABC mini-documentary that is under fire right now from many people. It’s too soon, we don’t have all the facts, the information is inaccurarte and it’s wrong to show, etc… Now, I’ll have to see it before I decide what I think…but it’s interesting that it has caused such an uproar. Perhaps because even though it’s a drama, it’s seen as more of a factual documentary as opposed to movies such as Flight 93 and World Trade Center.
And while it is important to remember this tragedy, it’s also going to fuel a lot more remembrance of the hatred and fear that many people felt causing the discrminiation against people from countries like Iraq and Afghanistan to be elevated yet again. Innocent people who don’t have ties to extremist groups or Muslims who follow the peace they seek are going to be seen as “taxi drivers by day and terrorists by night” all over again. Of course, there are those people among us who assimilate and do intend to cause harm to others…but no different than the person walking down the street planning to shoot a crowd of people, or the child bringing a gun to school, or even the other building bomb tragedies that have occured over the years. Which, is also to say, mostly done by caucasian males.
It’s hard to manage both remembering what happened and giving people the peace they desire. It’s difficult to separate threats from paranoia. And, it’s impossible to live now without the constant thought that someone, somewhere, is trying to hurt you. Airport travel, building security, and the way that people treat one another will perhaps never be the same, thanks to the war on terror and the miseducation of millions. Not to say that I know it all, or that I even understand everything…I too feel the annoyance and occasional slight fear of traveling on a plane, and I too notice when Muslims and other groups are discriminated against, and when more and more soldiers are dying.
To me, it’s not that the people who died on 9/11 “gave their lives to fight terrorism.” America didn’t completely know terror until 9/11, it wasn’t a daily part of our lives like it is for so many other people in the world. But, these people died because of terrorism, and now there are more dying in the war in Iraq because of it. Revenge is bittersweet. I’m not saying there is a clear or easy answer to any of this, and I’m not saying I’m right.
On this day tomorrow, and in the days that follow, I think it’s important to remember that we’re all in this together. We are all human - even extremist terrorist groups are someone’s brothers, fathers, sisters, mothers… and while many of the violent things that people do are unforgiveable and unfathomable…without taking a look at the bigger picture, nobody wins and nothing will ever be resolved. Maybe I’m just being an idealist and naive, but that’s what I think.
The strongest memory I have of 9/11, is of being on my college campus and the entire university coming together. The afternoon of, there was an elementary school style assembly in the theatre…and that night a candlelight vigil. Many students had parents and families in DC and NYC who were affected. I remember feeling the strength of so many gathered together in grief, confusion, and comfort. Some were angry and some were sad, and while it was a horrible reason to become one body, it was a powerful experience to all be bound by something that made us all the same.
So tomorrow, through the critics and the good and bad media coverage…just take a moment to remember that although it may be just another Monday…it also represents something much larger. America changed on 9/11/01…and I’m not sure if it will ever be the same.
*On a side note, don’t most people have to work? I mean, even if I wanted to sit and watch I couldn’t…
No Response for "Pre-9/11 Thoughts"
Was I the only one to see our sith lord Cheney come out of his crypt and make an ass of himself in front of Tim Russert today????????? Dude got clowned…
9-11 is linked to Afghanistan
Iraq is linked to “good opprutunity for new oil/my investment portfolio”…
One 9/11 was enough for me. I don’t need to relive it by watching it again every anniversary. Do we remember Pearl Harbor by sitting around watching real time video of the hours of bombing? Do we remember Oklahoma City by watching hours of searching through the rubble? Let’s remember the victims and focus on lessons learned.
I agree miles, lets not turn this into a ratings driven memorial ceremony.
Watch the coverage, don’t watch it. Whatever you desire. But fire years is just five years, even for the people directly affected and it’s important to keep moving life along and try to find solutions to the ills of the world.
It might be interesting to see that extremism is not only a non-Christian or non-white issue…look at the neo-fascist white supremist movements and extremism in the military (look up Intelligence Report in Southern Poverty Law Center movement).
Regarding the need of people for peace — the issue first and foremost is their need to feel safe and what might this include? Is it all about putting up walls or more security devices, or is it about elevating the trust among human societies? You might want to read the bishops’s handbook on this (I’ll send).
I do not believe that America changed on 9-11 2001…they might have been awakened…but they changed one month later when our President announced “In our anger we will find our purpose.” The reason why the experience at your school was so warm was because you were united in your grief which is the essence of our human condition… anger might be an appropriate feeling and is an excellent motivator but it must never be our reason for being or the source of our purpose….anger divides …. grief unites ….
“t’s also going to fuel a lot more remembrance of the hatred and fear that many people felt causing the discrminiation against people from countries like Iraq and Afghanistan to be elevated yet again”
Hatred was directed at more than just people from countries like Iraq and Afghanistan. Even people born and raised in the U.S., but with brown skin (think Indian ancestry) and often not even Muslim (alot of Sikhs) were targetted and discriminated against. Basically anyone who looked “arab” or “muslim” were misaken for arabs - some even paid with their lives in so-called “crimes of passion” - murdered taxi drivers and gas station attendants - VERY SAD! I’m not saying that anyone is deserved of a hate crime, but the whole discrimination thing has got to go. After ll that we lost on 9/11, we should not resolve to sheer idiocy: this is a disgrace to the memory of those that died on 9/11 and during the war.
Leave a reply